I had the same problem- right tear with fletchhunter release- not fixable. I shoot 29" 3-49 ACC with 125 gr point at 58 lbs. off a NAP 3000 rest. The Scott mongoose release I have will shoot bulletholes. I shoot off the string. So possibly try another release and let others shoot the bow if changing the rest does not work.
Also make sure that the cable guard set screws are tight.. Check for cam lean?? I had a limb go bad on a right handed bow and no matter what I did it wouldn't go away. Dick at Elite found the issue to be a limb that had went bad amd when I got the bow back it was perfect.